Advertisements
The Checkout Dilemma: The Choice Every Aussie Shopper Now Faces
You’ve been there. You’re at the digital checkout of The Iconic or JB Hi-Fi, your cart is full, and you’re ready to pull the trigger. Then you see it: the two little buttons that represent a massive shift in how we pay. One says, “Pay with Afterpay,” promising instant gratification. The other, “Enter Credit Card Details,” feels like the sensible, old-school choice.
It’s a decision millions of us make every day, often without a second thought. But the path you choose can have a real impact on your budget, your financial habits, and even your ability to get a home loan down the track. So, which one is actually the smarter choice, and why?
What’s the Deal with Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)?
Buy Now, Pay Later services like Afterpay and Zip Pay have absolutely exploded in Australia. They’re slick, they’re integrated everywhere, and their promise is incredibly simple: get your goods now and pay for them over a series of smaller, interest-free instalments. With Afterpay, for example, you typically pay the first 25% upfront, then the rest in three equal fortnightly payments.
The Good Bits: Why Aussies Love BNPL
There’s no denying the appeal. For many, BNPL feels less like a loan and more like a simple budgeting tool. The major upsides are clear:
Advertisements
- Simplicity and Speed: You can get approved in seconds with minimal fuss. There are no long application forms or waiting periods.
- Interest-Free Payments: This is the big one. As long as you make your payments on time, you won’t pay a cent in interest. It feels like free money.
- Helps Manage Cash Flow: Need that new washing machine but payday is a week away? BNPL can bridge the gap without you having to dip into your savings.
The Not-So-Good Bits: The Hidden Risks
Of course, nothing in life is truly free. The BNPL model relies on a few things to make money, and that’s where the risks for consumers come in:
- Hefty Late Fees: Miss a payment by a day and you’ll get stung. A single late payment on an Afterpay order can hit you with a $10 fee, with more to follow if you don’t catch up. These fees can quickly add up.
- The Psychology of Overspending: BNPL makes it dangerously easy to spend money you don’t have. Splitting a $200 purchase into four payments of $50 makes it feel cheaper, encouraging impulse buys and bigger spending habits.
- Potential Credit Score Impact: While the landscape is changing, many BNPL transactions don’t positively build your credit history. However, defaults and late payments can be recorded and may negatively impact your ability to get future loans.
And What About the Trusty Old Credit Card?
The credit card has been the king of convenience for decades. It’s a revolving line of credit that you can use almost anywhere, for almost anything. We all know how it works, but in the age of BNPL, it’s worth reminding ourselves of its core features and powerful benefits.
The Perks of Plastic: More Than Just a Payment Tool
Used responsibly, a credit card is one of the most powerful financial tools you can have. Its benefits go far beyond just paying for things.
- Building a Solid Credit History: This is a massive advantage. Every time you use your credit card and pay it off on time, you’re proving to lenders that you’re a responsible borrower. This is crucial for building a credit score in Australia, which you’ll need for a car loan or mortgage.
- Rewards and Points: Whether it’s Qantas or Velocity points for your next holiday, or cashback on your spending, credit card rewards can offer genuine value.
- Strong Consumer Protections: Many cards offer purchase protection insurance and fraud protection, giving you peace of mind. If you buy something faulty, you have a clear path for a chargeback.
The Potential Pitfalls: Where It Can Go Wrong
The biggest risk with a credit card is the temptation of its credit limit and the cost of its interest rates.
- High-Interest Rates: If you don’t pay your balance in full by the due date, the interest charges are brutal, often ranging from 15% to over 20% p.a. This is how small debts can snowball into big problems.
- Annual Fees: Many rewards cards come with an annual fee, which can range from under $100 to many hundreds for premium cards.
- The Debt Trap: The minimum repayment is a trap. Only paying the minimum can keep you in debt for years and cost you a fortune in interest.
The Minimum Payment Trap in Action:
Imagine a $1,500 debt on a credit card with 19% p.a. interest. If you only make the minimum repayment each month, it could take you over 15 years to clear the debt, and you’d pay almost $2,000 in interest alone. That’s more than the original cost of the item!Advertisements
Head-to-Head: Which Tool is Right for the Job?
Let’s put them to the test in a few common scenarios. There isn’t one winner for everything; it’s about using the right tool for the right job.
| Feature | Buy Now, Pay Later | Credit Card |
|---|---|---|
| Interest Rate | 0% if paid on time | High (e.g., 15-22% p.a.) if not paid in full |
| Late Fees | High and applied quickly | Can apply, but often after a grace period |
| Credit Score Impact | Neutral to Negative (defaults are bad) | Positive (if paid on time) or Negative |
| Rewards/Points | None | Yes (Points, Cashback, Insurance) |
| Consumer Protection | Limited | Strong (e.g., chargebacks) |
For a small fashion purchase…
You want a new pair of jeans for $200. Using Afterpay is simple, quick, and helps you spread the cost over your next few pay cycles. It works perfectly if you know for a fact the cash is coming in. A credit card also works, and you might earn a few rewards points. The credit card’s advantage here is purchase protection if the store’s return policy is difficult.
For a large, essential purchase (like a fridge)…
Your fridge dies and you need a new one for $1,500. BNPL might have a spending limit that prevents this purchase. A credit card gives you the immediate flexibility to buy it. Even better, this is a perfect time to look for low interest credit cards or cards with a 0% interest introductory period. This allows you to make a large, planned purchase and pay it off over several months without any interest at all—often a much better deal than BNPL.
For building your long-term financial reputation…
This isn’t even a contest. The credit card wins, hands down. When a lender assesses you for a home loan, they want to see a history of responsible credit management. A well-managed credit card is a giant green tick on your file. Performing a regular credit score check will show you exactly how your habits are shaping your financial future.
What a Mortgage Broker Sees:
When assessing your home loan application, a lender will scrutinise your bank statements. Seeing multiple, frequent BNPL transactions can be a red flag. To them, it might not look like smart budgeting, but like a reliance on small debts to manage your day-to-day spending, which can suggest poor cash flow.
The Big Picture: Beyond a Single Purchase
The real danger comes from juggling multiple payment methods. It’s easy to have a couple of Afterpay purchases, a Zip Pay account, and a credit card balance all on the go. This “debt stacking” can make it incredibly difficult to track your true financial position. If you find yourself overwhelmed, services for debt consolidation can help by rolling multiple debts into a single, manageable loan, but the goal is to avoid getting to that point in the first place.
The Forgotten Alternative: The Smart Debit Card
In the debate between two forms of credit, it’s easy to forget the most powerful option: spending the money you actually have. The humble debit card has had a modern makeover. Aussie neobanks like Up Bank and Xinja offer smart debit cards packed with features to help you budget better, automatically save, and track your spending in incredible detail. If the goal is to avoid debt, the smartest tool is often the one that doesn’t let you spend what you don’t have.
So, What’s the Smarter Choice for *Your* Wallet?
There’s no single right answer, but there is a smart approach. Neither BNPL nor credit cards are inherently “good” or “bad”—they are simply tools.
Think of it like this: Use BNPL as a budgeting tool, not a credit tool. If you have the cash available but just want to smooth out your spending between paycheques for a small purchase, it can work well.
Use a credit card as a financial tool. Use it for the rewards, the consumer protections, and to build a stellar credit history, but always—always—have a plan to pay it off in full before any interest is charged.
Ultimately, the smartest choice is conscious spending. Whichever button you click at the checkout, make sure it’s part of a plan, not just an impulse.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. Does using Afterpay or Zip actually affect my credit score in Australia?
It’s complicated and evolving. Historically, BNPL didn’t report to credit bureaus unless you defaulted. Now, under Comprehensive Credit Reporting, some BNPL providers are starting to report your repayment history. A missed payment could negatively impact your score, while on-time payments might be viewed positively. A history of many small BNPL loans could also be interpreted by lenders as a sign of financial stress.
2. Can I use my credit card to pay off my BNPL instalments?
Some BNPL services allow this, but it’s generally a bad idea. You’re essentially using a high-interest debt product (your credit card) to pay off what was originally an interest-free product. This is a classic sign of debt-shuffling and can lead to a debt spiral.
3. Are there any 0% interest credit cards that are a better deal than BNPL?
Yes, for large, planned purchases, they can be a much better option. Many banks offer cards with 0% interest on purchases for a promotional period (e.g., the first 12 or 18 months). This gives you a much longer, truly interest-free window to pay off a big-ticket item compared to the typical 6-8 weeks of a BNPL service.
